However, Etsy is MASSIVE. There are so many shops and to be honest some of them are pretty mediocre. There are a few ways to find the best things.
The first is to take the taste test. This is a test where you choose your favourites out of a group of items. It finds out your taste and then selects items that fit it.
The second is to look at the discover category. It again shows some of the best of Etsy.
You can also take a look at Etsy Milk - a blog that looks for the best in Etsy.